Sepsis is a macabre dance between host and pathogen. With development of germ theory by Lister, Semmelweis, Pasteur, and Koch, pathogen eradication was the focus. Only in recent decades, with observations by Roger Bone and others that patients succumbed to sepsis despite successful eradication of the pathogen, did attention swing to the host. It is now well accepted that a hallmark of sepsis is the systemic host immune response to infection that is directly injurious to vital organs. Unfortunately, the response is also extremely complex and highly variable in a way that is not easily appreciated from routine clinical examination or laboratory tests. This clinically elusive heterogeneity in the underlying pathogenesis of sepsis has bedeviled attempts to develop immune modulating therapies, with a litany of failed trials. The great hope is that success will lie in a strategy of precision therapy for sepsis, where a particular host response pattern can be identified swiftly and treated with more targeted interventions. Although ideas abound on how to measure and treat specific host-response patterns, the hope has remained largely theoretical, with little demonstration that it is practical and effective in clinical practice.